Dingobabies

You can say the same thing about Arcanist Belt, but it wouldnt really be the same thing. Arcanist Belt drops from Molten Core trash mobs. Someone could go to Molten Core with the intention of getting Arcanist Belt, because that is where it drops (quite regularly too). Nobody goes to LBRS to farm Stockade Pauldrons or any other world drop. If you really want Stockade Pauldrons, the only reasonable course of action is to farm/save gold and to buy it in trade chat or the AH. But hey, if people started running MC with group loot and without pre-defined loot rules and a T1 BoE that I could use would drop, I would expect everyone to smash that need button.

I'm sure that this has been said before, but I can't be arsed to read through 20 pages of comments. Anyway, what is the problem with needing on a valuable BoE that you can't use? It's a BoE, you can sell it on the AH, you can buy it on the AH. If Stockade Pauldrons are worth 300g (idk the actual price), then winning the item in a roll is essentially winning 300g. The mage can sell it on the AH for 300g, the warrior saves himself 300g by not having to buy it from the AH. If you really need a BoE item, buy it from the AH. If you're not going to do that, why should you be more entitled to it than anyone else?