I know this is ridiculous, but I recently got my hands on Quel'serrar after an extremely lucky drop in Dire Maul the other day. The DPS weapon I was using beforehand was Axe of the Deep Woods, which has a fairly dismal DPS of 41.5 -- but a rather nice weapon speed of 2.70, as well as a proc that causes an average of over 100 damage with a ~6% proc chance.
On impulse, I sold my axe, assuming Quel would be better. However, I've been OCD ever since about whether that was the right choice. Quel'serrar has 11 more raw DPS (52.5), which is an absolutely massive advantage -- but its weapon speed is only 2.0, and its top-end damage is lower, leading to less damage with Whirlwind / Overpower.
Which is the better DPS weapon, out of curiosity?
