Even though I'm new here I have plenty of experience in private servers. Usually private server communities tend to be a little bit more cosy. However this one feels like people hate each other because they want to play on a different realm?!! If you want to play in the old server, that's cool. If you want to play in the fresh server, that's cool aswell.
Players who choose join the fresh realm will start from scratch in return for a more populated(polls support this) server. Players who choose to play on the old realm will have everything back they had in return for a less populated server. However at the same time a more end-game based experience, rather than going through the same content again and again.