Edgemaster's Handguards and weapon skill

[Skarmbrena 0]

I've randomly heard from people that +weapon skill is bugged on this server. Some have said that anything about 310 is bugged, others say that everything over 300 is and doesn't work at all as intended.

Has anyone tested this and come to a conclusion whether or not weapon skill is working as intended?

I'm looking for (hopefully) several answers before I drop gold on Edgemaster's, or just go with Devilsaurs for fury. Thank you in advance for your responses.

[Vollfos 2]

go to the warrior forum there you get a perfect answer with calc for it , and anyone who says its bugged, dont know how it works.

 

edit: just forgot to say, Edgemasters gets his full potential in raids against lvl 61+ and bosses, using it in 5 man or ubrs isnt usefull and you need to reach 8%hit first before u use it propper. so if you dont get 8% hit without devilsaur,  you wont get the full dps boost effect from edgemasters.

[Haestingas 30]

Edgemasters is a no brainer, its BiS until Cthun gaunts.

[Ironsides 35]

4 hours ago, Vollfos said:

go to the warrior forum there you get a perfect answer with calc for it , and anyone who says its bugged, dont know how it works.

 

edit: just forgot to say, Edgemasters gets his full potential in raids against lvl 61+ and bosses, using it in 5 man or ubrs isnt usefull and you need to reach 8%hit first before u use it propper. so if you dont get 8% hit without devilsaur,  you wont get the full dps boost effect from edgemasters.

stop giving advice pls

[Skarmbrena 0]

Thanks for feedback so far. I'm aware of how weapon skill should work vs higher level mobs/bosses.

My question is, is > 300 weapon skill functioning as intended on Elysium? I've heard that it isn't from several people, and can't find a reliable source that proves one way or the other.

[Vollfos 2]

21 hours ago, Ironsides said:

stop giving advice pls

then give Skarmbrena a better advice. instead of just negate my statement of helping.

@Skarmbrena

first of al what do you mean with works it correctly ? 

correct to Vanilla 2005, or to other servers like Kronos , or just Nostalrius code ? ( which is using another calculation from hit-table) or what do you mean ?

 

from what ive seen at realmplayers 90% of the top 20 fury warriors at evrey of the 4 servers is using edgemaster handguard, so something should be right with it, if it works 100% correct to vanilla 2005 , dont know, but for the mangos code here its works proper.

[Justme 9]

16 hours ago, Vollfos said:

then give Skarmbrena a better advice. instead of just negate my statement of helping.

@Skarmbrena

first of al what do you mean with works it correctly ? 

correct to Vanilla 2005, or to other servers like Kronos , or just Nostalrius code ? ( which is using another calculation from hit-table) or what do you mean ?

 

from what ive seen at realmplayers 90% of the top 20 fury warriors at evrey of the 4 servers is using edgemaster handguard, so something should be right with it, if it works 100% correct to vanilla 2005 , dont know, but for the mangos code here its works proper.

just cause it's bis doesn't mean it's not bugged. It can be bugged beneficially (wich it's not btw, it works fine)

[Vollfos 2]

thats why i asked what "others " meant to be buggy,  i just think that the one which calls it buggy dont know how the + skill  works.

[Ironsides 35]

On 5/10/2017 at 9:01 AM, Vollfos said:

then give Skarmbrena a better advice. instead of just negate my statement of helping.

@Skarmbrena

first of al what do you mean with works it correctly ? 

correct to Vanilla 2005, or to other servers like Kronos , or just Nostalrius code ? ( which is using another calculation from hit-table) or what do you mean ?

 

from what ive seen at realmplayers 90% of the top 20 fury warriors at evrey of the 4 servers is using edgemaster handguard, so something should be right with it, if it works 100% correct to vanilla 2005 , dont know, but for the mangos code here its works proper.

the + weapon skill from edgemasters puts you in a different calculation bracket ONLY if you are 300 weapon skill rating. it's ~2% hit so there'd be no exaggerated difference (other than 2% less hit on your whites)  if you stuck it on with less than 8%

[Vollfos 2]

Yeah true, i never said something others, but, if you havnt 8,6%, he misses yellow dmg , whats the case to get more rage from offhand whitehits if your execute ( for example) could miss. thats why it would be better to get 8% from gear before you uses edgemaster. (to get the full dps potential, what i said) 

and next diffrend, dont know how it is on hordeside, but edgemaster get sold on alliance for 1k gold, but you can get devilset for about 300 gold. if you have enough money, ok, but not , im pretty sure the devilsaur set would  be a better invest for e fresh 60 

[Storfan 24]

2 hours ago, Vollfos said:

Yeah true, i never said something others, but, if you havnt 8,6%, he misses yellow dmg , whats the case to get more rage from offhand whitehits if your execute ( for example) could miss. thats why it would be better to get 8% from gear before you uses edgemaster. (to get the full dps potential, what i said) 

and next diffrend, dont know how it is on hordeside, but edgemaster get sold on alliance for 1k gold, but you can get devilset for about 300 gold. if you have enough money, ok, but not , im pretty sure the devilsaur set would  be a better invest for e fresh 60 

Edgemasters+Cloudkeepers would make you done with those gear slots until Ouro/Cthun in AQ40. For Devilsaur there are numerous upgrades before AQ40.

[Vollfos 2]

Storfan : Alliance AH today

- Edgemaster 1000 gold

-Cloudkeeper not available yet last seen, sold for 1300g

 

fresh 60 hasnt that gold normally , so 300 spending on Devilsaur set is worth till geting this gold. i mean you could say to him get rank 12 for Legs ....